It’s health care financing, stupid

Go look at the graphs Ezra Klein has in this post. They clearly show that Social Security has no financial problem going forward and that it’s health care costs which are ballooning out of control. The really good news is that the guy whose think tank produced the charts is giving the keynote at President …

Continue reading ‘It’s health care financing, stupid’ »

Benefit cuts for the many

The Center on Budget Priorities and Policy has published a summary of what Mr. Bush proposed last night. In last night’s press conference, President Bush endorsed a proposal that would result in substantial cuts in benefits for middle-income families and deeper cuts for higher-income families. While the proposal was described as reducing benefits for the …

Continue reading ‘Benefit cuts for the many’ »

Price versus wage indexing

In the great Social Security debate there’s been some discussion of converting from wage-indexing to price-indexing. This is the best explanation I’ve seen so far: Using the term “indexing” to describe what is being proposed creates confusion and makes a simple proposal seem complex, so let me try to clarify it. Right now, Social Security …

Continue reading ‘Price versus wage indexing’ »

“No Man is an Island”

Jonathan Chait has an excellent explanation of the reasons why Bush’s SocSec plan needs to be defeated. Privatizers portray Social Security as a kind of low-performing 401(k) plan. But the program was never intended as a personal retirement plan. It’s a form of social insurance, designed to spread risks throughout the population. One such risk …

Continue reading ‘“No Man is an Island”’ »

De-beatify Alan, please

In light of these remarks from Chairman Greenspan, it’s instructive to read this article by Greg Anrig, Jr., pointing out that on Social Security, Alan Greenspan (Maestro, as Woodward’s book called him) has no clothes. Over the past two decades, Greenspan has repeatedly argued that Reagan’s “ironclad commitment” should be broken. Year after year, he …

Continue reading ‘De-beatify Alan, please’ »

Don’t tax me, tax the guy under the tree

Here’s a question for Mr. Bush: if your (asinine) plan for private accounts went through, would the payouts from those accounts be taxable income? …while the retirement account might be “money that the government can never take away,” the government usually “takes away” some of citizens’ income through taxation. Would retirees’ withdrawals from their retirement …

Continue reading ‘Don’t tax me, tax the guy under the tree’ »